The Firm You Go to When the 
Stakes Are High

DOJ Continues to Pursue False Claims Act Cases Against FHA Mortgage Lenders and Auditors

Despite recent comments from Housing and Urban Development Secretary (“HUD”) Ben Carson implying that the government would be less aggressive toward mortgage fraud enforcement, the Department of Justice continues to pursue False Claims Act cases for fraud against the Fair Housing Administration (“FHA”) mortgage insurance programs.

The False Claims Act (FCA) is the government’s primary enforcement tool for prosecuting fraudulent civil claims. For companies that are found liable for illegal activity, damages can total three times the amount lost by the government as a result of the fraud, plus penalties associated with each false claim. The FCA requires that the falsified claims be made “knowingly” and be “material” to the payment made by the government. These criteria preclude a company from liability for an inadvertent or inconsequential administrative error, or a violation that would not be relevant in the government’s decision to make payments.

FHA Traditional Mortgages

The FHA insures loans to assist lower and moderate-income Americans in purchasing homes. The loans insured by the FHA are originated through private lenders approved by the FHA. In 2016, settlements and verdicts against the mortgage industry under the FCA totaled $1.7 billion. The majority of these cases involved FHA lenders who were charged with improper conduct in originating forward mortgages. The government has collected more than $7 billion since 2009 from settlements for fraud associated with these loans, and the federal government has continued to aggressively pursue these claims. In the past, these fraudulent activities have included non-conforming underwriting and origination practices, failure to adhere to quality control measures, and deficient reporting of defective loans to HUD.

  • The Justice Department obtained a settlement for $65 million with PHH Mortgage as a result of its certification that residential mortgages were entitled to FHA insurance even though they did not satisfy the applicable requirements to decrease the risk of default. PHH skirted reporting obligations as mandated under the FHA program. The endorsement of unqualified loans for federal insurance resulted in inflated mortgage profits and exposed borrows to unreasonable risks.
  • Allied Home Mortgage Capital Corporation and Allied Home Mortgage Corporation paid the federal government over $296 million for violations of the FCA and the Financial Institutions Reform, Recovery and Enforcement Act of 1989 (FIRREA). The claims were based on falsified assertions by Allied that certain loans qualified for FHA insurance. Allied then filed insurance claims with FHA upon default of those loans. Allied’s quality control department also produced falsified reports to auditors that endorsed that Allied fully conformed to quality control guidelines established by the US Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD). In addition, these loans originated from over one hundred bogus offices that were established to avoid scrutiny by the FHA.
  • IBERIABANK Corporation, IBERIABANK and IBERIABANK Mortgage settled allegations that the companies falsely verified that the loans it originated qualified for FHA insurance protection. As a “direct endorsement lender” under the FHA program, IBERIABANK is authorized to underwrite and endorse mortgages without pre-approval from the FHA. For these types of lenders, the FHA does not confirm compliance with its regulations before the loan is endorsed. FHA insurance claims were paid on certain loans that contained discrepancies regarding the borrower’s income, inadequate data about appraisal values, and faulty information about the borrower’s down payment. In addition, IBERIABANK Corporation improperly issued incentive payments to underwriters for originating these loans.

Reverse FHA mortgages

Increased scrutiny by the Justice Department of FHA-insured reverse mortgages comes in the wake of signs that the reverse mortgage industry may be experiencing a resurgence. The industry has seen some growth in application filings as reverse mortgages are being presented as viable options for financial planning for retirees. A reverse mortgage is a tool that allows older homeowners to convert some part of their equity into cash without mortgage payments. Mortgage insurance is provided by the FHA in order to protect lenders in these mortgage commitments. FHA insured reverse mortgages are referred to as Home Equity Conversion Mortgages (HECM). Servicers of HECM loans must strictly adhere to the servicing requirements for reverse mortgages in order to obtain payments from the government. When servicers of HECM loans engage in activity that exploits federal programs and violates the law, the FCA enables the government to pursue claims for compensation.

  • Financial Freedom, a reverse mortgage servicer, resolved claims that it improperly requested payments from an FHA insured reverse mortgage program. Financial Freedom paid $89 million to the government to settle charges that it received interest payments from FHA for unqualified HECMs between 2011 and 2016. The company’s failure to adhere to program guidelines negatively affected borrowers. Financial Freedom foreclosed on over 35,000 homes during this time. The whistleblower in the case received $1.6 million for her participation in the case.
  • Walter Investment Management Corporation agreed to pay over $29 million in 2015 to settle charges that it committed violations concerning HECMs, including submitting fraudulent claims for debenture interest on HECM loans. This case was brought subject to the qui tam provisions of the FCA and the whistleblower earned $5.15 million for his role in the case.
  • United Shore Financial Services, one of the leading wholesale mortgage lenders in the country, entered into a settlement with the federal government over allegations that the company knowingly originated and underwrote mortgages that were not in compliance with FHA standards. As a “direct endorsement lender,” United Shore failed to adhere to FHS standards when underwriting its loans. United Shore agreed to pay $48 million in the settlement.

Liability for FHA Mortgage Auditors

In addition to cases against FHA mortgage lenders and servicers, independent auditors tasked with signing off on FHA lenders’ compliance may also be liable for turning a blind eye to violations and fraud. In February 2018, the Department of Justice announced that “Big Four” auditor Deloitte and Touche had agreed to pay $149.5 million to settle allegations that it failed to perform its FHA mortgage audit obligations for defunct FHA lender Taylor, Bean, and Whitaker Mortgage Corp. All FHA Direct Endorsement Lenders are required to engage an independent auditor to ensure compliance with FHA and HUD regulations. By failing to detect the lender’s violations, Deloitte and Touche allowed the lender to submit materially false and misleading financial statements.

If you have knowledge and proof that a company or individual is defrauding a government program, including the FHA Mortgage Insurance Programs, call us today for a free consultation and case review with an experienced whistleblower attorney. To review your eligibility, contact the whistleblower attorneys at Levy Konigsberg, LLP for a free confidential consultation at (800) 315-3806.

WHISTLEBLOWER NEWS

A TEAM COMMITTED TO DOING WHAT IS RIGHT

Find out whether you have a case by speaking to one of our experienced mesothelioma lawyers via our 24/7 toll-free hotline or by submitting an email inquiry. Our attorneys will be quick to respond to you and happy to answer all of your questions.

Know the Difference

Committed to Doing What's Right
  • Over $3 Billion Won

    We have represented numerous individuals and groups of workers, winning for them multi-million-dollar settlements and verdicts.

  • There's No Case Too Big

    Our team has achieved groundbreaking victories in highly complex cases and has gone up against some of the toughest defendants in the country.

  • Trial Attorneys

    Our attorneys excel in the courtroom and are not afraid to bring a case in front of a jury if a fair settlement for the client has not been reached.

  • A Thought Leader in the Industry

    Our firm's knowledge and experience are in high demand, and many news outlets have asked us to share our legal expertise.

  • Access to World Class Resources

    Our experienced attorneys use cutting-edge technology and highly regarded experts to help us achieve the best possible result for our clients.

  • Changing the World for Good

    We not only want to achieve the best possible results for our clients, but we also strive to prevent future harm by changing public health policies.

Thousands of Clients Helped

Hear What They Have to Say
  • They truly made a difference in our lives!

    “Levy Konigsberg went above and beyond in representing my father in his mesothelioma case against multiple parties. From providing a risk free introduction (even flying out at their expense to speak to my father in person) to fighting diligently for us.”

    - Jonathan McNulty
  • Outstanding law firm!

    “Jerry and Bob are not only experts in their field, but genuinely care about their clients. They explain the entire process in a step like manner and are keenly aware that the health and medical treatment of the defendant should not be compromised.”

    - R.M.
  • No need to look any further.

    “The attorneys were attentive to my fathers needs during all proceedings while at the same time aggressive with the defendants making sure my father got everything he deserved.”

    - Todd Allen
  • They were the clear choice!

    “Jerry Block was compassionate and assembled a team of attorneys that knew exactly what to do. Although no amount of money can replace my father, we are grateful to them for giving him the gift of knowing that his family would be taken care of.”

    - Bruce Totterdale
  • Forever grateful!

    “They were not only knowledgeable but also compassionate. It was comforting to know they were diligently working on his case so we could focus on his medical care. Levy Konigsberg became part of our journey and we are forever grateful.”

    - Diane Hoefer
  • The best and brightest!

    “They never failed to keep us informed of all important developments in the case, and they always gave a realistic idea of when the matter would be resolved. I always felt that my dad was excellently represented, and that his case was in the best hands.”

    - Paulette
  • Simply incredible!

    “Corey Stern was simply incredible! Not only did he keep me well informed as to what was transpiring with my case, but was direct and honest all the way through. His hard work and compassion resulted in an amazing settlement.”

    - IBS LMM
  • Knowledgeable guidance and representation.

    “Your firm explained all of the steps involved in filing my case, took the time to update me as it progressed, prepared me for my meeting with NYS officials… Without your knowledgeable guidance and representation, I may not have been successful.”

    - Steven Simon
  • They are good people who want to help you.

    “I am now in a more comfortable financial situation. I can now go out and buy myself the things I need, without worrying how I am going to do that. Because I am well aware that I am not capable of getting or keeping a job.”

    - Edwin Jimenez
  • They won us a lot of money.

    “Levy Konigsberg, in my opinion, is a great law firm. They took very well care of us and I believe that they cared very much about our case. They were great attorneys.”

    - Karen
LEVY KONIGSBERG IN THE NATIONAL MEDIA

CHOOSE LEVY KONIGSBERG

Start with a FREE Consultation
  • Please enter your first name.
  • Please enter your last name.
  • Please enter your phone number.
    This isn't a valid phone number.
  • Please enter your email address.
    This isn't a valid email address.
  • Please make a selection.
  • Please enter a message.